Group for those with intellectual disabilities wants meeting with justice minister

Michael MacDonald, The Canadian Press
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

HALIFAX – A Nova Scotia group that speaks for people with intellectual disabilities is calling for a meeting with federal Justice Minister Peter MacKay, saying federal laws must be changed to stop the criminalization of people with special needs.

Victor Murphy, left, and Cindy Carruthers of People First Nova Scotia answer questions during a press conference at St. James Anglican Church on Monday. Mr. Murphy is the father of Amanda Murphy, who is a special needs adult facing criminal charges

Cindy Carruthers, co-ordinator for People First Nova Scotia, told a news conference Monday that people with cognitive impairment are too often being charged for aggressive behaviour that should be dealt with outside the criminal justice system.

“These crisis situations can be minimized and perhaps even eliminated with appropriate housing, effective staff … and good programs,” said Carruthers, who has worked in the field for 20 years. “There should be more effective responses when someone loses control other than calling the police.”

A spokeswoman for MacKay did not specifically say whether MacKay would meet with the group.

“We are constantly reviewing the Criminal Code to ensure it remains relevant to Canadians,” Paloma Aguilar said in an email. “Our government is always open to suggestions on means to make the federal justice system more responsive and efficient.”

The province’s Community Services Department responded with an emailed statement pointing out that each care-giving facility in the province develops its own policies on when to call police.

“Police are only called as a last resort in situations of imminent danger when other less intrusive interventions fail and the person exhibiting the aggressive behaviour is a threat to themselves or other residents, staff or bystanders,” the statement said.

A spokesman for Nova Scotia Justice Minister Lena Diab issued a statement saying anyone who feels they are in danger has the right to call police.

“Once police are called to a situation, they are trained to be sensitive to people’s needs and abilities and to assess carefully whether charges should be laid,” the statement said.

Carruthers said unless the federal laws are changed, Nova Scotians can expect to see another case similar to that of Ashley Smith, the mentally ill New Brunswick teenager who died in a federal prison when she strangled herself in her cell, prompting a public inquiry.

Smith was transferred between institutions 17 times in the 11 months before she died at the age of 19. Her parents say she never received the psychological help she needed.

Victor Murphy, a paramedic from Truro, N.S., spoke at the news conference about his 34-year-old daughter Amanda, who will be sentenced next month for assaulting a worker at a group home in Antigonish even though she has the mental capacity of an eight-year-old.

“I’m kind of disappointed in the staff that they would … file assault charges rather than work something out,” he said, adding that his daughter is epileptic, bipolar and has an attention deficit disorder.

“Amanda is just a child, but now she’s being treated as a criminal. Quite honestly, she can’t help what she does. … She’s a woman trapped in a child’s body.”

Another parent, Brenda Hardiman, said she and other parents of children with intellectual disabilities will be staging a series of protests across Nova Scotia on Feb. 2, with tentative plans for rallies in Halifax, New Minas, Truro, Windsor and Yarmouth.

“We do not criminally charge, convict and incarcerate people with Alzheimer’s or someone that experiences epileptic seizures,” she said, adding that Nova Scotia’s mental health court hasn’t helped with her daughter’s case.

“We’re hoping that the premier and Peter MacKay will take a lead on this and take a good look at it. It’s just morally wrong.”

Hardiman met with Premier Stephen McNeil last week after the Truro woman launched a campaign to draw attention to her daughter’s plight.

Nichele Benn, 26, was charged with assault and assault with a weapon after she allegedly bit and hit an employee at the Quest Regional Rehabilitation Centre in Halifax on Dec. 12. Benn, who lives at the centre, has epilepsy, cerebral palsy and an organic brain disorder that her family says causes her to have aggressive behaviour.

Hardiman said Benn previously lived with a couple in a home in rural Nova Scotia, but when that arrangement ended several years ago there wasn’t an appropriate, small group home available for her.

McNeil made no commitments after meeting with Hardiman, but he said the Community Services Department would take a closer look at the case.

Organizations: People First Nova Scotia, Community Services Department, Quest Regional Rehabilitation Centre

Geographic location: Nova Scotia, Truro, Halifax New Brunswick Antigonish New Minas Yarmouth

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page



Recent comments

  • rachele saulnier
    January 22, 2014 - 11:48

    my son is on the autistic spectrum and has a head injury and a mental illness. 3 years ago he went to jail for not complying with a court order to stay away from his girlfriend, even though the girl kept showing up at his door and calling him. He was assaulted in jail multiple times and went into solitary confinement multiple times just to avoid conflict. He was in solitary confinement on Christmas day that year. There was no help from the mental help team to keep him out of jail. he was put on medication in jail and I had to constantly pursue this with the psychiatrist in jail and even had to contact my MP. There needs to be more help for these people.